A beloved World War II photo comes to life in a virtual reunion
By Elisabetta Povoledo
Martin Adler was a 20-year-old private first class in the 339th Infantry Regiment in 1944 when he and a fellow soldier went door to door in an Italian town looking for German troops.
They entered a house and saw a large basket. It was moving. Assuming they had found what they were looking for, they prepared to fire, screaming at whoever was inside to come out.
Suddenly, a woman ran into the room yelling at them to stop. The top popped off the basket, and three small children emerged.
The two American soldiers began laughing in relief. The meeting was memorialized in a photograph with Adler and the children in their “Sunday best.”
When Adler’s daughter, Rachelle Adler Donley, was looking recently to bolster him after months of quarantine, the photo was where she turned.
Late last month, Adler Donley shared the photo on several World War II-themed internet groups, along with an appeal: “Trying to find these children from Italy. My dad Martin Adler, 96 years old, would be overjoyed. Please share.”
“I was looking for ways to cheer him up,” Adler Donley, a former art director for a book publisher, said of the search for the children. The past year, she added, had been “really, really hard” on her father, who lives in a retirement community in Florida, where he has been apartment-bound with his wife, Elaine, 89, since March.
“I thought, let me post this and see if there’s a chance,” she said.
The photo caught the attention of Matteo Incerti, the author of several books about World War II, including one published this year on the history of the Indigenous people of Canada and the United States in the Italian campaign. Incerti was familiar with war records, and he quickly tracked down the position of Adler’s company in the fall of 1944, along the Gothic Line in the Apennine Mountains, which crossed the regions of Tuscany and Emilia Romagna. But he wasn’t sure about the exact location.
He asked for help on social media and got local journalists on board. Articles were published in city newspapers in central Emilia-Romagna. Last weekend, TG1, the main 8 p.m. news program of Italy’s principal television station, Rai 1, broadcast a segment with the appeal.
Bruno Naldi, 83 and living in Castel San Pietro Terme, near Bologna, said his niece had seen the photograph on TV and had immediately called Giuliana — Naldi’s sister — to say, “It’s you.” The next day he met with his sisters, Mafalda, 81, and Giuliana, 79, and they agreed that the three of them were indeed the children in the photograph.
Incerti put them in touch with Adler in Florida, and they had a virtual reunion last week, an event broadcast on TG1.
Naldi said his mother, Rosa Minarini, never said anything about the American soldier who had taken a photograph of them — and nearly killed them. Or maybe she had, and he had just forgotten, he said, explaining, “We didn’t speak much about these things.”
Adler Donley said that until five years ago her father, too, hadn’t spoken much about his war years. “Growing up, there were very few stories he would tell,” and the story of the children was “one of them,” she said in an interview from her home in North Carolina. “He would always tell this story with such joy.” His other war stories mostly brought on nightmares, she said.
Adler always described his meeting with the children as “the happiest moment of the war; the only happier moment was when the war ended,” she said. “That smile in that picture is so genuine,” she said.
The Naldi siblings have become media celebrities here in Italy, a spot of good news in a country hit especially hard by the coronavirus. Bruno Naldi said his phone had rung so much it “was burning.” Mafalda, his sister, said she couldn’t wait for the media interest to pass. “Even the stones are talking about us,” she said.
Bruno Naldi said Adler told them that once it was safe to travel again, he wanted to visit Italy “to see where he was during the war and to come and meet us to hug us,” he said. “I was fine when we spoke on Monday afternoon,” he said, “but when I saw it again on TV, I cried.”
Adler Donley said the reunion was emotional on her family’s end also. “I think my father is really feeling the love, and he and the rest of the veterans who fought in the Italian campaign really deserve the recognition,” she said. “He’s always said to me, for as long as I can remember, ‘I want to be the last World War II veteran alive.’”