After 30 years, Rutgers finds its way back to the NCAA Tournament
By Matt Sugam
Jim Calhoun knows a thing or two about building something out of nothing, and it turns out that Steve Pikiell, now the Rutgers coach, was paying close attention all those years ago.
Over 26 seasons as Connecticut’s head coach, Calhoun turned a lousy, unknown program into a national brand, winning three national titles and 17 Big East championships — 10 regular-season and seven tournament titles — before retiring in September 2012.
In conference games, his Huskies typically dominated the perpetually struggling Scarlet Knights, but the trips to Piscataway, New Jersey, led Calhoun to believe Rutgers could build a powerhouse if it wanted.
He would share this notion with Pikiell, a point guard who was with him from the beginning of his UConn tenure. When Pikiell first slipped on a UConn jersey in the mid-1980s, he was asked in airports if he played for a team in Fort Yukon, Alaska. No one had heard of the university in the sticks of Storrs, Connecticut, and people were confused by the wolfish Husky mascot.
But Calhoun knew he had something to pitch to players.
“We went out and we sold the Big East — and eventually, we sold UConn,” Calhoun said by phone this past week. “But initially, the Big East was magical, and I think right now the Big Ten is. You watch Illinois play, Michigan playing, et cetera, et cetera, you’re watching arguably the best conference in the country.”
He added, referring to Pikiell: “All those venues — it isn’t a game. It’s an event at those places. It’s tradition rich. He’s using the Big Ten like we used the Big East.”
Sell the conference, sell the team.
When interviewing with Rutgers’ athletic director, Pat Hobbs, five years ago, Pikiell said he would walk the New Jersey Turnpike from his coaching job at Stony Brook on Long Island if it meant he could lead Rutgers, which hadn’t reached the NCAA Tournament since 1991.
He wasn’t deterred by Rutgers’ reputation as a program that chewed up and spit out coaches.
Kevin Bannon nearly led Rutgers to the NCAA Tournament in 1999 but was fired in 2001 after the “naked free-throw incident” during his first season in 1997 — players and managers were ordered to run sprints naked after losing a strip free-throw contest — received renewed attention.
Gary Waters nearly took Rutgers to the tournament in 2004. He resigned after the 2006 season, in which he had missed a game against Marquette.
Waters’ replacement, Fred Hill Jr., was fired in 2010 for a profanity-laced tirade directed at Pittsburgh coaches at a Rutgers baseball game. Then came Mike Rice, who then went in a scandal over abusive behavior. Eddie Jordan, a star guard from the university’s 1976 Final Four team, took the job in 2013 after three unsuccessful stints as an NBA coach. He went 29-68.
The program got used to losing and being the butt of jokes in the Big East — the nation’s premiere college basketball conference at the time — before a one-year stopover in the American Athletic Conference in 2013-14. The program’s last NCAA appearance had been three conferences prior, as a member of the Atlantic 10.
When Jordan was fired, Rutgers had lost 33 of its previous 34 conference games, playing home games in half-empty arenas.
Pikiell, who had risen to challenges before, still wanted the job.
The 53-year-old Pikiell was the architect who had led Stony Brook to its first NCAA Tournament and into a new on-campus arena. As a player at UConn, he was often injured and was a two-time captain when the program finished last in the Big East in 1986-87. The Huskies went on to win the conference title when he was a senior in 1989-90 and advanced to the Elite Eight at the NCAA Tournament.
At Rutgers, recalling Calhoun’s advice, Pikiell quickly found players to buy in. The first was Geo Baker, a low-ranked recruit who wore No. 0; Pikiell turned him into a senior captain and a clutch-shot-making all-Big Ten player and the face of the program.
Myles Johnson, another work in progress, crossed the country to join the team and became an academic all-American engineering major headed to graduate school and an all-Big Ten center.
“If you look at Myles when he first came in, I wouldn’t have seen what he is like now,” Baker said of his teammate Johnson, a 6-foot-11, 255-pound redshirt junior. “I have no idea how the coaches saw that vision. They’ve done a great job of just continuing to develop us and make sure we understand the game, while also developing us as people.”
Ron Harper Jr. has an NBA pedigree through his father, Ron, who won five championships with the Bulls and the Lakers, but the younger Harper was also an unheralded recruit. Under Pikiell, Harper blossomed into an all-conference player who is regarded as one of the top small forwards in the country and an NBA prospect.
“I bet everybody on the roster, when they committed to Rutgers, everybody asked them, ‘Why?’” Harper said. “I remember when I committed, when I’d play away games in high school, opposing student sections would chant ‘last in the Big Ten’ and talk trash about Rutgers.”
But Harper’s decision helped spearhead the rebuilding.
Rutgers went to the 2018 Big Ten tournament quarterfinals. In 2019, Pikiell’s third year and Harper’s freshman season, Rutgers improved to seven conference wins, and last year it won 11.
The Rutgers Athletic Center grew raucous and became one of the toughest places in the country for visiting teams to play. With a program-record 10 sold-out games, including nine straight at the end of the 2019-20 season, Rutgers went 18-1 at home in a 20-win campaign. Then a dream season ended abruptly, as the coronavirus pandemic shut down the NCAA Tournament that Rutgers had been striving toward.
“They didn’t feel the pressure of 29 years like they felt the pressure this year, because you were right there, playing well,” Hobbs said. “And now of course this year, you got to get back there. Was last year real, if you don’t get back there?”
It’s real. Rutgers beat Clemson, 60-56, in the first round Friday — its first NCAA Tournament win since 1983 — and was to face Houston on Sunday. And Calhoun has continued to watch the Scarlet Knights.
“It’s just a matter of vision right now, instead of esteem, which is good,” Calhoun said, adding that he would tell Pikiell: “OK, you’ve got there. The key is, getting there is really tough. Staying there? Sometimes tougher.”