How a baseball outsider became the Yankees’ pitching guru
By James Wagner
The man who led the New York Yankees’ pitching staff through the seesaws of this truncated regular season, and who will soon guide them into a unique postseason, never played professional baseball. The highest level he reached was pitching for the College of the Holy Cross. His earned run average over four years there: 6.54.
His degree is in psychology and philosophy. His first foray into learning about the intricacies of the body’s movement came from online forums, books and DVDs.
Before Matt Blake became a self-taught pitching instructor just over a decade ago, he was a salesman for a marketing company in his hometown, Concord, N.H. As recently as five years ago, he was coaching high school baseball, and now he is the Yankees’ pitching coach.
“It’s for the better,” Yankees reliever Adam Ottavino said of Blake’s background.
Baseball can be a slow-moving, ritualistic sport. Things are done a certain way because they always have. In recent years, though, some of the most innovative work in the sport has come from outside the professional ranks, so clubs have snatched up coaches from colleges and private training facilities, like Driveline Baseball or Cressey Sports Performance.
“When you’re in the private sector, you’re a speedboat,” Blake said in an interview earlier this year. “You can go wherever you want as fast as you want and it’s your decision how much you want to spend and who you want to learn from and where you want to go and what you want to do.”
But professional baseball, he said, is “a tanker in the middle of the ocean. If they want to go a different direction, they have to turn 150 employees around, and a lot of them have been doing it a long time.”
The Yankees may be a tanker, but they were already turning when Blake arrived. Over the past two years, they hired several people from outside professional baseball to help them with what general manager Brian Cashman often calls the “new world order” of Major League Baseball.
Sam Briend (the director of pitching) and Daniel Moskos (a minor league pitching coach) were lured from Driveline. Desi Druschel (manager of pitch development) came from the University of Iowa. Three other minor league pitching coaches — Dustin Glant, Ben Buck and Brett DeGagne — also jumped from the college ranks.
When the Yankee set out last winter to replace Larry Rothschild, their longtime pitching coach who skewed old-school in his coaching style, they interviewed two college coaches. But Blake, 35, the Cleveland Indians’ director of pitching development, set himself apart with his resume and ideas.
In 2016, he jumped from baseball’s private sector — he was the pitching coordinator at Cressey Sports Performance — to Cleveland. There, he became an important piece of their envied pitching factory, helping develop standouts like Shane Bieber, Mike Clevinger and Zach Plesac, until the Yankees lured him away in November. Blake is now one of four pitching coaches in the major leagues without professional playing experience.
Sitting in an office at the Yankees’ spring training facility in Tampa, Fla., before the pandemic struck, Blake acknowledged that it had been a wild journey from leaving his sales job to setting up his own pitching instruction business to becoming a sought-after pitching guru who landed with the Yankees.
“But on the other hand, every step made sense,” he said. He developed a unique skill set, he said, that combined an understanding of the movement of the body, video analysis, analytics, pitching strategies and strength and conditioning.
In other words, Blake became the epitome of a modern pitching coach. He grew up understanding the needs of the contemporary pitcher, from using weighted balls to high-tech cameras. In Cleveland, he was known for his ability to translate advanced data into usable instruction.
“He’s extremely intellectual in regards to baseball, pitching, people and personalities,” Bieber, the leading contender for the 2020 American League Cy Young Award, said earlier this year. “We loved having him here.”
While Blake may not have as much experience with mound visits or in-game management, the Yankees’ ace Gerrit Cole said Blake had caught up quickly this season. Blake arrived, Cole said, with “a large tool belt.”
“He’s been around enough people to talk simple pitching, like ‘stay back’ or ‘get through the baseball,’” Cole said, adding: “He touches all parts of the realm.”
From a young age, Blake gravitated toward his coaches. While working a sales job for nearly two years after graduating from college in 2007, he was earning more money teaching pitching to youth players on weekends. He was also devouring coaching resources, from books to online forums to videos, of pitching instruction from experts like Ron Wolforth and Paul Nyman.
Fascinated by a DVD in which Eric Cressey broke down the movements of a player joint by joint, Blake reached out to him in 2009 through a mutual friend. Cressey introduced Blake to the head coach of Lincoln-Sudbury Regional High School in Massachusetts. Blake became the school’s pitching coach for six years, winning a state title in 2011.
At the same time, Blake was building the pitching arm of Cressey’s training business into one that attracted the two-time Cy Young Award winner Corey Kluber, then with Cleveland, during offseasons.
Blake’s even-keeled nature during his first season with the Yankees — in a pandemic-shortened season, no less — has impressed Manager Aaron Boone, though he acknowledged that Blake was still learning the intricacies of a major league season and communicating daily with a sprawling staff like the Yankees’.
“Everything I’m seeing is that he’s going to be really good at this,” Boone said recently.
From the beginning, in his first meetings with players in spring training, Blake emphasized that he hoped his expertise would be a supplement, not a replacement, to theirs or other coaches’.
“There’s definitely a level of respect for the talent that you’re coaching,” he said. “I have not played the game at that level. But if you’re upfront and authentic about that and not try to pretend that you did, I don’t think players care anymore.”