‘Younger’ departs a COVID-free New York, a fantasy to the end
By Kathryn Shattuck
“Younger” has always been escapism at its fantastical best: A New York of dazzling Manhattan skyscrapers and tastefully grungy Brooklyn lofts. A 40-ish divorced woman battling workplace ageism by passing as a 20-something, with enticing romantic possibilities in each age group. A publishing industry where even an assistant can afford designer threads she doesn’t need to wear twice.
Or, as it turns out, color-coordinate with a mask while socially distancing from her equally glamorous colleagues. Because when “Younger” returns Thursday for its seventh and final season, it will be as if the pandemic never happened. (In a move that will likely vex at least some longtime fans, the new season will run first on the Paramount+ streaming service and then air on TV Land, its original home, later this year.)
True to form, “Younger” left hearts dangling in September 2019 when, in the Season 6 finale, Charles (Peter Hermann) finally asked Liza (Sutton Foster) to marry him — and the episode ended before she could answer.
But just as the series was to begin shooting last spring, bringing closure to that stomach-knotting will-she-won’t-she moment, the COVID lockdown shuttered the television industry, delaying the season’s premiere by roughly 10 months. And Darren Star, the show’s creator, and his writers found themselves with a cliffhanger not of their own making: Would they or wouldn’t they incorporate the pandemic into the show’s farewell season?
Several episodes had already been written by September, when Star said in interviews that he was considering ways to integrate it into the series as the season progressed.
“We did think about it,” he said recently by phone. “But we would have had to create a big time-jump, which felt artificial and contrived. Even if we had done it, I think there were some drawbacks sitting there last summer and imagining how things would play out a year from now. You don’t want to guess wrong about how these characters are behaving.”
Ultimately, they voted to leave the pandemic out.
“I think we all felt like everyone’s sick of it,” said Dottie Dartland Zicklin, a writer and executive producer. “They don’t want to see it.”
Foster, for one, was happy to keep “Younger” in its bubble. “‘Younger’ is always taking whatever is happening in the world or the zeitgeist, and then we flip it,” she said. “But ‘Younger’ is also this wonderful escape, and there’s nothing funny about the pandemic. It’s horrific and heartbreaking and half a million people have died, and what do you do with that on the show?”
Meanwhile, another spirited discussion was transpiring in the writers room around how to wrap up Liza’s story seven seasons in. Would she get the man? And if so, would it be Charles, the age-appropriate head of Millennial, the publishing house where Liza works? Or Josh (Nico Tortorella), the much younger Williamsburg tattoo artist? Would her career at Millennial continue to soar, or would it land with a thud?
Zicklin, who is closer to Liza’s age and had struggled with career and family herself, felt that she could speak directly to the Gen X experience. Other female writers were more philosophically in tune with the millennial Kelsey (Hilary Duff), Liza’s colleague and friend.
“I love hearing their perspective because I think the show, thematically, is generational,” Zicklin said. Discussions about the two main aspects of Liza’s story — love and career — highlighted that divide, starting with the topic of marriage.
“I come from the old school where if you don’t want to marry somebody, that means you’re just not into them,” Zicklin said. “These young women are like: ‘No, no, no, no, no. There are a million reasons you don’t want to be married, and you can still love the person and want to be a partner.’”
The concept of female success, too, is different in 2021 from what it was in the ’90s, when Zicklin tended to give her professional female characters tight hair buns, power suits and miserable lives alone at home with cats.
“In this show, both Liza and Kelsey are very focused on their career, and they don’t come out like pinched spinster schoolmarms,” she said. “They’re well-rounded women who a career is an important part of their life, just like it would be for any male character.”
The land of “Younger” may have been pandemic-free, but there were health restrictions, mandatory testing and the occasional shutdown to contend with when shooting began in October. Ultimately Miriam Shor, who stars as Diana, Millennial’s imperious head of marketing, and Charles Michael Davis, who plays Zane, Kelsey’s competitive editor-beau, were unable to resume their regular roles because of scheduling and COVID-related issues; they will appear only in cameos. As a result, “we had to reengineer a lot of the story,” Star said.
Toward the end of the season, Hermann pitched Star a way to subtly acknowledge what was happening in the outside world. In the final episode, Charles shows Liza a treasured vintage typewriter as the camera focuses on its brand: Corona.
“In a sense, the pandemic does live in our show because it plays in New York, and the city just looks spectacular in the way that the show shoots it,” Hermann said. “But I think that in this case, the city has never been more beautiful. There is this stately resilience and this fierce, determined elegance and then just this badass grit.”
The final hurdle in the writers room was how to deal with Liza’s lie, which began as a rather comedic way for her to get hired in an ageist industry but then snowballed into something more serious.
“Her lie does have a cost,” Foster said, leaving it at that.
Hermann and Foster shot their final scene together on Feb. 26, wrapping at 5 a.m. outside the Bowery Ballroom on the Lower East Side.
“It was just the two of us, and we looked around on the sidewalk, and there were our writers and our crew and our director, with the garbage trucks rumbling by,” Hermann said. “We were so happy and so sad and so deeply grateful.”
Written by Star, the series finale “is just very elegant and heartbreaking and hopeful and joyous and optimistic,” Hermann added. “And it’s a hard-won optimism, which is also embodied in Sutton. I think that her spirit and her determined, positive outlook on life really, really got us through.”
After years of speculation about whether Liza would get her fairy-tale ending — and about what that might be exactly — did the show land on the one Foster would have written herself?
“It feels like there’s no other way to end it,” she said. “I wouldn’t have known until I read it — and I went, ‘Oh, yeah.’”